The September 2010 Daring Bakers’ challenge was hosted by Mandy of What the Fruitcake?! Mandy challenged everyone to make Decorated Sugar Cookies based on recipes from Peggy Porschen and The Joy of Baking.
"Sugar cookies?!" I can hear you saying. "What's so challenging about sugar cookies?" Ah, but these are not the haphazardly-smeared-on icing kind. These are the fancy, delicate, painstakingly piped kind, and as such were definitely a worthy challenge for ever-intrepid Daring Bakers!
I happen to own two of Peggy Porschen's books,
Cake Chic and
Pretty Party Cakes. Each of these books is an absolute feast for the eyes, showcasing not only her stunning cakes but also wonderfully detailed sugar cookies in all shapes and styles, decorated with royal icing. The Daring Bakers were given the theme of "September" for our cookies - whatever that might happen to mean for us. I was excited to read about this month's challenge, not only because I've spent plenty of time ogling the chapters in Peggy's books, but also because a very special event happened this month, one particularly well suited to cookie-adaptation.
Some of the prettiest and most elegant cookies I've seen in this genre are dress cookies - like the ones above, or
these,
these, and
these. The pure whiteness of royal icing and the delicate lines and piping are the perfect medium for recreating the elegance of wedding dresses in miniature. No, no, not
my dress. Our wedding was in July, and two years ago to boot. The absolute highlight of this September was flying to the States two weeks ago to be one of the maids of honor in my best friend Julia's wedding.
Julia's favorite color is purple and for years I've looked forward to the day I would wear a purple dress in her wedding. Each of the five bridesmaids were given our
choice of neckline, and as you can see we all chose quite differently. With all these pretty dresses fresh in my mind, both cookie and real, the choice for my Daring Bakers theme was a no-brainer!
I began by drawing and cutting out templates to use as cookie-cutters for the dresses.
I traced around the templates with a clean X-acto knife on the rolled-out cookie dough and once baked, followed the simple recipe for royal icing - just powdered sugar, egg whites, and lemon juice. The coloring was a bit more difficult since I didn't want to use an entire bottle of purple food coloring to get the color as dark as the actual dresses... at least the white turned out right! First, I piped the outlines of the dresses using a thicker consistency of icing and a very small tip, then used a technique called "flooding" to fill them in. The same color icing in a thinner consistency is piped inside the outlines, which act as a barrier to stop the liquid from dripping off the edge of the cookie. With a little help from a toothpick and some taps on the counter to settle it into place, the thinner icing forms a smooth layer. After it dries, the outlines are re-piped with the thicker icing to provide definition and detail.
Though you can't see it in the photo, Courtney and I both had ivory-colored sashes and double hems to mark our maid-of-honor statuses, while the other bridesmaids had dark-blue double hems.
I really enjoyed this challenge and was particularly pleased by how well Julia's dress-cookie turned out. The method is incredibly time- and material-heavy (cookie cutters/templates, piping bags, tips, food colorings), though, especially if you choose a design with lots of different colors - you could truly spend all afternoon just decorating and adding details to one batch of cookies. If you'd like to try your hand at it, you can find the complete recipe in printable version
here.
Even more wonderful than cookies, of course, was the chance to be part of Julia's special day. After many years and many, many conversations between us about boys and our futures, my dear dear friend is finally married to the man of her dreams and I wish them many sweet and happy years together!
Congratulations, Julia & Ben!